第四节 主要内容和框架
本书着重分析了军工复合体政治关系中的运行网络关系、参政途径和对美国现行政治体制提出的挑战、作用和影响,进而分析美国民主稳定的合法性问题。笔者首先提出了本书的命题假设并界定了书中涉及的概念,分析了军工复合体产生和演化的过程。重点分析了军工复合体的政治关系,这里面运用两章的篇幅分析了军工复合体搜集信息的政治关系网络和对政府决策施加的政治影响。随后分析了军工复合体对经济、科技和外交的影响,从而构成军工复合体对美国内政外交的全面认识。
除绪论和结论外,本书共分六个部分。
第一部分主要提出了本书的命题,界定了书中涉及的概念,进一步分析了军工复合体的特征、产生原因和演化过程。第二部分和第三部分主要集中于对军工复合体的政治关系分析,第二部分分析了军工复合体在搜集信息中的政治关系网络,第三部分分析了军工复合体施加政治影响的途径和机制,从中透视军工复合体对美国民主秩序的挑战和影响。第四部分分析军工复合体与美国经济的关系,包括国民经济军事化和重塑美国经济版图。第五部分解析了军工复合体与美国科技发展的关系。这部分侧重分析军工复合体塑造美国科研政策和体系、科研军事化,以麻省理工学院和斯坦福大学作为案例进行分析。第六部分则是着重分析了军工复合体对美国外交的影响,尤其是美国外交军事化倾向和军工复合体对外交议题的主导。结论部分对以上分析进行了总结,认为美国军工复合体不仅是美国民主秩序的破坏性力量,还是维护其稳定的积极力量,并从中看到美国民主的内在矛盾和局限。军工复合体是美国民主稳定的双刃剑:限定在政治合法性的共识基础上的是积极因素,作为一个社会组织过度扩权超过这个冲突界限则是消极因素。
[1]Seymour Martin Lipset,“Some Social Requisites of Democracy: Economic Development and Political Legitimacy”,The American Political Science Review,Vol.53,No.1,March 1959,pp.69-105.
[2]Jack Raymond,Power at the Pentagon,New York: Harper & Row,1964,p.262.
[3]Jack Raymond,Power at the Pentagon,p.264.
[4]Wayne S.Cole,Senator Gerald P.Nye and American Foreign Relations,Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press,1962,pp.79-81.
[5]Guiles Davenport,Zaharoff,High Priest Of War,Boston: Lothrop,Lee and Shepard Company,1934.
[6]H.C.Engelbrecht,F.C.Haneghen,Merchants of Death: A Study of the International Armaments Industry,New York: Dodd,Mead,1934.
[7]George Seldes,Iron,Blood and Profits: An Exposure of the World-wide Munitions Racket,New York:Harper & brothers,1934.
[8]Harold D.Lasswell,“The Garrison State,”American Journal of Sociology,ⅩLⅥ,1941,pp.455-468; Lasswell,“Does the Garrison State Threaten Civil Rights?”,The Annals,CCLXXV,1951,pp.111-116; Lasswell,“The Garrison State Hypothesis Today,”in Samuel P.Huntington,ed.,Changing Patterns of Military Politics,New York: Free Press of Glencoe,1962,pp.51-70.
[9]Hanson W.Baldwin,“The Military Move In,”Harper's,CXCV,1947,pp.481-489.
[10]William O.Douglas,“Should We Fear the Military?”,Look,XVI,March 11,1952,p.34.
[11]C.Wright Mills,The Power Elite,New York: Oxford Press,1956,p.276.
[12]Fred G.Cook,The Warfare State,New York: International Publishers,1963; Irwin Suall,The American Ultras: The Extreme Right and the Military-industrial Complex,New York: New American,1962; Victor Perlo,Militarism and Industry: Arms Profiteering in the Missile Age,New York: International Publishers,1963.
[13]Marcus Raskin,“A National Security State,”The Progressive,ΧΧΧΙΙΙ,July 1969,pp.5-6.
[14]Juan Bosch,Pentagonism: A Substitute for Imperialism,New York: Grove Press Inc.,1968.
[15]Richard J.Barnet,The Economy of Death,New York: Atheneum,1969.
[16]Murray L.Weidenbaum,“The Defense-Space Complex: Impact on Whom?”,Challenge,ΧΙΙΙ,April 1965,pp.43-46.
[17]Julius Duscha,Arms,Money,and Politics,New York: I.Washburn,1964; L.L.Nieburg,In the Name of Science,Chicago: Quadrangle,1966; John Kenneth Galbraith,The New Industrial State,Boston: Houghton Mifflin,1967; Galbraith,How to Control Military,New York: Doubleday and Company,1969; Ralph E.Lapp,The Weapons Culture,New York: W.W.Norton,1968.
[18]L.L.Nieburg,In the Name of Science,pp.380-381.
[19]Arthur M.Schlesinger,Jr.,The Crisis of Confidence: Ideas,Power,and Violence in America,Boston: Houghton Mifflin,1969,pp.165-174.
[20]Jack Raymond,Power at the Pentagon,New York: Harper & Row,1964,pp.319-334.
[21]John M.Swomley,The Military Establishment,Boston: Beacon Press,1964; John M.Swomley,“Economic Basis of the Cold War,”Christian Century,LXXXV,1968,pp.581-585.
[22]Tristam Coffin,The Passion of the Hawks: Militarism in Modern America,New York: Macmillan,1964 and The Armed Society: Militarism in Modern America,Maryland: Penguin Books,1964; G.William Domhoff,Who Rules America?,Englewood Cliffs,N.J: Prentice-Hall,1967,pp.115-131.
[23]Sidney Lens,the Military-Industrial Complex,Philadelphia: Pilgrim Press,1970; Michael T.Klare,“Science for the Pentagon: The Secret Thinkers,”Nation,CCVI,1968,pp.503-504.
[24]Marc Pilisuk,Thomas Hayden,“Is There a Military Industrial Complex Which Prevents Peace? Consensus and Countervailing Power in Pluralistic System,”Journal of Social Issues,XXI,January 1965,pp.67-117; Anonymous,Report from Iron Mountain: on the Possibility and Desirability of Peace,New York: The Dial Press,1967.
[25]Kenneth Boulding,“The Role of the War Industry in International Conflict,”Journal of Social Issues,XXII,January 1967,pp.54-55.
[26]J.B.Colwell,“Nation Needs Military Industrial Link to Survive,”Los Angeles Times,July 20,1969,p.3.
[27]William Hyland and Richard Shryock,The Fall of Khrushchev,New York: Funk & Wagnalls,1968;Richard Armstrong,“Military Industrial Complex: Russian Style,”Fortune,LXXX,August 1,1969,pp.84-87,122-126.
[28]Adam Yarmolinsky,Establishment: It's Impacts on American Society,New York: Harper & Row,Publishers,1971,p.420.
[29]Carroll W.Pursell,The Military-Industrial Complex,New York: Harper & Row,Publishers,1972,p.12.
[30]Sam C.Sarkesian,The Military-Industrial Complex: A Reassessment,London: Sage Publications,1972,p.ⅶ.
[31]Herbert I.Schiller and Joseph D.Phillips,Super State: Readings in The Military-Industrial Complex,Chicago: University of Illinois Press,1972.
[32]Benjamin Franklin Cooling,War,Business,and American Society: Historical Perspectives on the Military-Industrial Complex,New York: Kennikat Press,1977.
[33]Gordon Adams,The Politics of Defense Contracting: The Iron Triangle,New York: New Brunswick,1982,p.216.
[34]Paul A.C.Koistinen,The Military-Industrial Complex: A Historical Perspective,New York: Praeger Publisher,1980,p.99.
[35]David Wise and Thomas Ross,The Invisible Government,New York: Vintage Books,1974.Reprint of the 1964 Random House edition,p.352.
[36]Charles Allred Cannon,The Military-Industrial Complex in American Politics,1953-1970,Dissertation,1974.
[37]Richard K.Betts,Soldiers,Statesmen,and Cold War Crises,Cambridge: Harvard University Press,1977.
[38]Max L.Stackhouse,The Ethics of Necropolis: An Essay on the Military-Industrial Complex and the Quest for a Just Peace,Boston,Mass: Beacon Press,1971.
[39]Steven Rosen,Testing the Theory of the Military-Industrial Complex,Lexington,MA: Lexington Books,1973.
[40]Sidney Lens,The Military-Industrial Complex,Philadelphia: Pilgrim Press,1970.
[41]Baumgartner and John Stanley,The Lonely Warriors: Case for the Military-Industrial Complex,Los Angeles: Nash Publishing,1970.
[42]James L.Clotfelter,The Military in American Politics,New York: Harper & Row,1973.
[43]John C.Donovan,the Cold Warriors: A Policy-Making Elite,Lexington,Mass.: D.C.Heath,1974.
[44]Fox J.Ronald,Arming American: How the U.S.Buys Weapons,Boston: Harvard University,1974,p.10.
[45]Ann Markusen and Joel Yudken,Dismantling the Cold War Economy,New York: Basic Books,1992,p.ⅩⅥ.
[46]James L.Clayton,ed.,The Economy Impact of the Cold War: Sources and Readings,New York:Harcounrt,Brace & World,Inc.,1970,p.281.
[47]Robert W.DeGrasse Jr.,Military Expansion,Economic Decline: the Impact of Military Spending on U.S.Economic Performance,Armonk,New York: M.E.Sharpe,1983,p.160.
[48]Ann Markusen,Peter Hall etc.,the Rise of the Gunbelt: the Military Remapping of Industrial America,New York: Oxford University Press,1991.p.3.
[49]Gregory Michael Hooks,Forging the Military-Industrial Complex: World War II's Battle of the Potomac,Chicago: University of Illinois Press,1991,pp.263-264.
[50]Merton J.Peck and Frederic M.Scherer,The Weapons Acquisition Process: An Economic Analysis,Boston: Harvard University,1962,p.595.
[51]Thomas E.Kelly,“The Concrete Road to MIC: National Defense and Federal Highways”,In Benjamin Franklin Cooling,War,Business,and American Society: Historical Perspectives on the Military-Industrial Complex,National University Publications Kennikat Press,1977,p.133.
[52]Kenneth R.Mayer,The Political Economy of Defense Contracting,New Haven: Yale University Press,1991,p.224.
[53]Stuart W.Leslie,The Cold War and American Science: The Military-Industrial-Academic Complex at MIT and Stanford,New York: Columbia University Press,1993,p.256.
[54]Merritt Roe Smith,ed.,Military Enterprise and Technological Change: Perspectives on the American Experience,Cambridge,Massachusetts: the MIT Press,1985,p.348.
[55]David Dickson,The New Politics of Science,New York: Pantheon,1984.
[56]Stephen Archibald Cobb,The Military-Industrial Complex and Foreign Policy,Dissertation,1971.
[57]Gordon Adams,“Disarming the Military Subgovernment,”Harvard Journal on Legislation,14,No.3,April 1977.
[58]Itzhak Galnoor,“Government Secrecy: Exchanges,Intermediaries and Middlemen,”Public Administration Review,35: 1,January,1975.
[59]Marc Pilisuk,Thomas Hayden,“Is There a Military Industrial Complex Which Prevents Peace? Consensus and Countervailing Power in Pluralistic System,”Journal of Social Issues,XXI,January 1965.
[60]刘恩东:《军工复合体与冷战后的美国外交政策》,硕士学位论文,中共中央党校,2008年。
[61]李春梅:《军工复合体与美国外交政策的制定》,硕士学位论文,吉林大学,2006年。
[62]朱文江:《美国军工—思想库复合体与小布什对外政策》,《国际资料信息》2008年第2期。
[63]章节根:《美国军工复合体与美国的军控政策》,硕士学位论文,复旦大学,2003年。
[64]桑红:《当代美国军事经济与军事霸权的关系:兼论军工利益集团的影响》,硕士学位论文,河北师范大学,2001年。
[65]韩宇:《冷战时期军工复合体对美国科学发展的影响》,硕士学位论文,厦门大学,2008年。
[66]章嘉琳:《变化中的美国经济》,学林出版社1987年版。
[67]佟福全:《新经济:美国经济长久不衰之奥秘》,中国经济出版社2001年版。
[68]阎晓杰、李文兴:《美国军工产业发展与加工业转移的主要做法及启示》,《北京交通大学学报》(社会科学版)2007年第3期。
[69]赵克尽:《美国军工集团与中美关系》,《和平与发展》2004年第3期。
[70]杨斌:《美国霸权战略与军工、石油垄断财团利益》,《开放导报》2006年第3期。
[71]宋玉华:《后冷战时期美国军事工业的重组、发展及其影响》,《世界经济与政治》2004年第9 期。
[72]彭晓枫:《军工产业在当代社会发展中的地位》,《战略与管理》1999年第6期。
[73]杨明杰:《美国国家安全战略决策中的军工“铁三角”》,《现代国际关系》2002年第7期。
[74]张春燕:《美国军工综合体与国家导弹防御系统》,《云南社会科学》2002年第5期。
[75]孙哲:《美国国会与中美关系:案例研究与分析》,时事出版社2004年版,第7页。
[76][法]托克维尔:《论美国的民主》(上),董国良译,商务印书馆1997年版,第186页。