第17章 PROBLEMS AND LIMITATIONS(2)

Another point which is capable of being used against us is this: The spirits have the greatest difficulty in getting names through to us, and it is this which makes many of their communications so vague and Page 88unsatisfactory.They will talk all round a thing, and yet never get the name which would clinch the matter.There is an example of the point in a recent communication in Light , which describes how a young officer, recently dead, endeavoured to get a message through the direct voice method of Mrs.Susannah Harris to his father.He could not get his name through.He was able, however, to make it clear that his father was a member of the Kildare Street Club in Dublin.Inquiry found the father, and it was then learned that the father had already received an independent message in Dublin to say that an inquiry was coming through from London.

I do not know if the earth name is a merely ephemeral thing, quite disconnected from the personality, and perhaps the very first thing to be thrown aside.

That is, of course, possible.Or it may be that some law regulates our intercourse from the other side by which it shall not be too direct, and shall leave something to our own intelligence.

This idea, that there is some law which makes an indirect speech more easy than a Page 89direct one, is greatly borne out by the cross-correspondences, where circumlocution continually takes the place of assertion.Thus, in the St.

Paul correspondence, which is treated in the July pamphlet of the S.P.R., the idea of St.Paul was to be conveyed from one automatic writer to two others, both of whom were at a distance, one of them in India.Dr.Hodgson was the spirit who professed to preside over this experiment.You would think that the simple words "St.Paul" occurring in the other scripts would be all-sufficient.But no; he proceeds to make all sorts of indirect allusions, to talk all round St.Paul in each of the scripts, and to make five quotations from St.Paul's writings.This is beyond coincidence, and quite convincing, but none the less it illustrates the curious way in which they go round instead of going straight.If one could imagine some wise angel on the other side saying, "Now, don't make it too easy for these people.Make them use their own brains a little.They will become mere automatons if we do everything for them" -- if we could imagine that, it would just cover the case.Page 90Whatever the explanation, it is a noteworthy fact.

There is another point about spirit communications which is worth noting.This is their uncertainty wherever any time element comes in.Their estimate of time is almost invariably wrong.Earth time is probably a different idea to spirit time, and hence the confusion.We had the advantage, as I have stated, of the presence of a lady in our household who developed writing mediumship.She was in close touch with three brothers, all of whom had been killed in the war.This lady, conveying messages from her brothers, was hardly ever entirely wrong upon facts, and hardly ever right about time.There was one notable exception, however, which in itself is suggestive.Although her prophecies as to public events were weeks or even months out, she in one case foretold the arrival of a telegram from Africa to the day.Now the telegram had already been sent, but was delayed, so that the inference seems to be that she could foretell a course of events which had actually been set in motion, and calculate how long they would take Page 91to reach their end.On the other hand, I am bound to admit that she confidently prophesied the escape of her fourth brother, who was a prisoner in Germany, and that this was duly fulfilled.On the whole I preserve an open mind upon the powers and limitations of prophecy.

But apart from all these limitations we have, unhappily, to deal with absolute coldblooded lying on the part of wicked or mischievous intelligences.Everyone who has investigated the matter has, I suppose, met with examples of wilful deception, which occasionally are mixed up with good and true communications.It was of such messages, no doubt, that the Apostle wrote when he said: "Beloved, believe, not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God." These words can only mean that the early Christians not only practised Spiritualism as we understand it, but also that they were faced by the same difficulties.There is nothing more puzzling than the fact that one may get a long connected description with every detail given, and that it may prove to be entirely a concoction.

However, we must Page 92

bear in mind that if one case comes absolutely correct, it atones for many failures, just as if you had one telegram correct you would know that there was a line and a communicator, however much they broke down afterwards.

But it must be admitted that it is very discomposing and makes one sceptical of messages until they are tested.Of a kin with these false influences are all the Miltons who cannot scan, and Shelleys who cannot rhyme, and Shakespeares who cannot think, and all the other absurd impersonations which make our cause ridiculous.They are, I think, deliberate frauds, either from this side or from the other, but to say that they invalidate the whole subject is as senseless as to invalidate our own world because we encounter some unpleasant people.